Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Rhodes scholar who claimed she was poor loses place at Oxford (standard.co.uk)
12 points by pinewurst on Jan 14, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 6 comments


A sign of the times it seems. This is what happens when so much of how one constructs oneself is as a mere product of circumstance. We are of course, but something in the culture is weirdly centering it.


> A sign of the times it seems

Not even close.

People do immoral, unethical or illegal things if they see an advantage in doing so.

People have been doing such things since well before the onset of recorded history.

In some circles, it's even celebrated (Uber, AirB&B...)


Jeez, she is more than middle class, she is upper middle class, 750k home in st.louis is huge, and Whitfield private school is very expensive. It is like if Mark Zuckerburg claimed to be from the streets. One thing i will say is i've also seen plenty of underrepresented minorities who are pretty much upper middle class or just rich, claim racial hardship and whatnot to get really good opportunities (Imagine if Obama's children wrote an essay about how hard their lives have been cause they are black). I guess there will always be people who will use dirty tactics to get ahead. One i particularly love is when a friend i had in high school, used the immigrant experience to try to get into his target school, like both of his parents were doctors lol


Unless I'm missing something, she seems to be a student, possibly estranged from her family since 17, having spent the last year of her adolescence in foster care, so it's plausible that she is currently poor, and needing of a scholarship to afford further education.

We don't know any more details from this article, and there is a big difference between having grown up poor verses being currently poor, as ones early life can give them a huge advantage, but this might not be as clear cut of a case of "rich kid blatantly lies to get opportunity" as it may seem.


Fake it until you make it or get caught.

Lots of people lie to get ahead.

She will apologize, maybe, all will be forgiven and she will go on to great things riding on the successes of her wealth.


The last paragraph of the article suggests she's already gotten away with it...

"Withdraw your application for this scholarship or we're going to show what we found to the police and let them decide".




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: